Er zijn geen gezondheidsvoordelen voor wie wijn drinkt. Dat zeggen de wijn-ontraders die daarvoor allerlei studies en onderzoeken opvoeren. Van recente datum is een wereldwijd onderzoek waarin naar voren kwam dat consumptie van vijf of zes glazen wijn per week geen zelfvernietiging betekent, nadat ‘duiders’ aan de resultaten een verkeerde draai hadden gegeven. Die zeiden zelfs in koor dat elk glas extra een half uur van je leven zou kosten. Dan maar wat korter, maar wel plezieriger, was de algemene reactie van wijndrinkers. In ons land heeft Harold Hamersma een boek gepubliceerd over de manier waarop wijn-ontraders opereren. Ze voeren in meerderheid onderzoeken op, die hun vermeende gelijk bevestigen.Wat is er nu wel of niet waar? Daar heeft de WSET-studente Mirela Mart zich nog eens over geboden. Ze veegde opnieuw allerlei onderzoekresultaten bij elkaar en constateerde wat we al weten: matig wijn drinken kan ook risico’s op fysieke ontregeling verminderen. Lees hier haar bevindingen i n het artikel The surprising health benefits of wine, verschenen op de website Vincarta.
“I grew up thinking that wine or other alcoholic drinks had no health benefits. In fact, I believed that alcohol should be banned from the face of the Earth. As a result, I was teetotal until almost 23, despite my poor father trying to make me have a drop of booze from time to time. He used to say: ‘child, don’t be such a Spartan, drink a sip of alcohol once in a while, it will disinfect your gut!’
And look at me now. I’m studying for my WSET diploma and I have started a wine business. You could say I’m making up for lost time.
While working for the World Bank, I travelled a lot to Croatia. During dinners with my colleagues, I started drinking a glass or two of wine and I discovered I liked it. I still have fond memories of me bringing one or two bottles of wine wrapped carefully in my clothes on my return. That habit stuck with me, as I always have space in my suitcase for a couple of bottles of wine every time I travel to a wine-making country.
Drink wine responsibly
I strongly believe in healthy eating, exercise, quality sleep and a balanced, healthy lifestyle. I also believe that we should enjoy alcohol with moderation, especially if we want to avoid a hangover.
That’s why, when I started the wine diploma, I wanted to research whether the reported health benefits of wine are a myth or if there is some scientific truth behind them. I have spent a lot of time reading about this and I have included a partial list of sources at the end of the article.
But let me start with the bare facts: moderate wine consumption appears to be good for your health.
‘It is well established that in Western populations, moderate drinkers live longer than non-drinkers, who in turn live longer than heavy drinkers. In fact, an alcohol consumption of 2.5-14.9 grams/ day (one or two drinks) results in a 14-25% reduction of risk of cardiovascular diseases compared with abstainers.’
Wine Science: The Application of Science in Winemaking, Jamie Goode
We all know that people from countries with a moderate drinking culture like France, Spain and Italy live longer and have less heart diseases incidents than the Brits.
So moderation is important: better to drink well-made wine in small doses, with food, spread out over the week. There are no health benefits to binge drinking. DrinkAware recommends a maximum of 14 units a week for men and women – that’s about six large glasses of wine. The Drinkaware app, which we reviewed recently, can help you keep track.
Moderate drinkers live longer than non-drinkers, who in turn live longer than heavy drinkers.
Drinking moderately wine might cut your risk of cardiovascular disease by 25%. This is one of the main wine health benefits.
Wine contains powerful antioxidants, which are arguably more effective than vitamin C and E. They bind with free radicals and will prevent the formation of clots in our blood vessels. You can’t go wrong here, as all the antioxidants will chase away free radicals, no matter which colour you chose. This leads to lower incidence of heart attack. In addition, the wine mix of alcohol and polyphenols has an anti-inflammatory effect similar with aspirin.
Due to its natural aspirin-like properties, wine helps with atherosclerosis (the formation of fatty cells on our arteries). So, if you are thinking of eating that fat piece of Stilton, better have it with a glass of wine! The degree of protection is similar with the one achieved by exercising regularly. But, this does not mean that you can replace exercise with wine, no matter how appealing the thought might be. While you might get the same anti-inflammatory benefits, this will be shorter term, as the calories from the alcohol will start showing on your waistline.
At the University of Barcelona, epidemiological and clinical studies suggest that moderate consumption of wine (one or two glasses per day) leads to decreased incidence of some diseases. They mention: cardiovascular disease hypertension, diabetes and certain types of cancer (including colon, basal cell, ovarian, and prostate carcinoma).
Wine helps increase ‘good’ HDL cholesterol
Drinking alcohol in moderation has a beneficial effect on cholesterol level. Alcohol increases the HDL (high-density lipoprotein) cholesterol and reduces the LDL (low density lipoprotein) cholesterol. The HDL cholesterol carries cholesterol away from the cells and back to the liver, which processes it again. LDL cholesterol carries cholesterol to the cells that need it. But, if there is excess cholesterol for the cells to use, it can build up in the artery walls.
If we have too much LDL cholesterol levels, this makes us prone to stokes and heart attacks.
In Wine Science, the author quotes a study which points that moderate consumption of alcohol seems to be acting as a good drug.
‘The degree of HDL cholesterol increase is better than what can be achieved with any single therapy’.
Boost your antioxidants, reduce your waistline
Rather than diet
Red wine consumption helps with waist circumference and obesity, probably due to the polyphenols
An occasional glass of white or red wine may help to improve the blood sugar levels reducing the risk for type two diabetes
Wine contains resveratrol, a substance produced by plants during times of stress (bad weather, pest attack). It protects them from fungal diseases. In humans, besides being an antioxidant, it can help prevent cancer and acts as an antibiotic against harmful bacteria. (However, the jury is still out, according to other sources). However, proves exits that wine consumption enhances gut microbiota.
Resveratrol in red wine contains and enzyme caller which has the property to increase life span. In the laboratory, it increased the life of yeast cells and fruit flies by 70%. We achieve the same life-prolonging effect by reducing our calorie intake by one-third. I guess most people would chose to drink a glass of wine rather than be on a perpetual diet.
Light to moderate wine intake lowers the risk of dementia.
Wine has high levels of potassium, which play a crucial role in counteracting the negative effects of salt in our diet. It replaces the sodium in the body, meaning that, in many ways, wine is also a vitamin supplement.
The old advice is the best: drink in moderation, enjoy responsibly and choose well-made wine (and food) instead of additive-heavy, mass-produced plonk. Chose carefully what you are drinking and make out the most of the wine health benefits.
‘After all, wine has been consumed for centuries and was always regarded as a healthy, regular beverage, provided it is consumed with moderation.’
Understanding Wine Technology, David Bird, Chartered Chemist & Master of Wine
The old advice is the best: drink in moderation and choose well-made wine
More information about the health benefits of wine:
- Understanding Wine Technology, Third Edition, David Bird
- Wine Science: The Application of Science in Winemaking, James Goodie
- Wine, beer, alcohol and polyphenols on cardiovascular disease and cancer, Arranz S1, Chiva-Blanch G, Valderas-Martínez P, Medina-Remón A, Lamuela-Raventós RM, Estruch R
- Effects of red wine polyphenols and alcohol on glucose metabolism and the lipid profile: a randomized clinical trial. Chiva-Blanch G1, Urpi-Sarda M, Ros E, Valderas-Martinez P. Casas R, Arranz S, Guillén M, Lamuela-Raventós RM, Llorach R, Andres-Lacueva C, Estruch R.
OIV: Closing remarks from Professor Rosa María Lamuela-Raventós, University of Barcelona.